Cherrybook.
Gotham Coffee Roasters

Blue Mountain

Medium-Light★ 4.7 (19)72Cherry's Index

Cup profile

mild · smooth · chocolate · nutty

Blue Mountain by Gotham Coffee Roasters
Origin
—
Producer
—
Farm / Co-op
—
Process
—
Altitude
—
Varietals
—
Harvest
—
Weight
200g
Bag price
$12.00
Price / oz
$1.70/oz
Brew
—

from the roaster’s storeread by Cherrybook from the listing“estimated” below = inferred, not stated

Buy on Gotham Coffee Roasters →

Price and availability set by the roaster.

Save at Gotham Coffee RoastersFree shipping over $25loyalty/rewards program

Cherrybook last checked this listing 5 days ago.

Cherry's Index

Evidence-of-quality score, not a cup score. Methodology

72

Noted

Preliminary

Confidence35% coverage / 3 of 7 signals

Score is partially shrunk toward a neutral 50 — read directionally until more source families land.

How confidence affects the score

Coverage measures signal availability, not cup quality. Missing sources are dropped, remaining weights are renormalized, and the result is shrunk toward a neutral 50 baseline by 13% so one thin signal cannot carry the score on its own.

Missing: SCA grade, Coffee Review, YouTube reviews, Cherrybook tastings

  • Buyer reviews
    On-shop star ratings (Yotpo, Reviews.io, Okendo, Loox, Stamped, Judge.me)
    92/ 34% weight
  • Reddit sentiment
    Sentiment across specialty-coffee discussion
    75/ 51% weight
  • Roaster transparency
    Producer / farm / lot disclosure depth
    20/ 14% weight

Bonuses applied

  • Sprudge press coverage
    This roaster has been featured by Sprudge
    +2

Renormalized base 73.0 shrunk to 70.1 at 88% confidence + bonuses = 72.

Sensory profileestimated

Flavor wheelestimated

Comps & alternatives

Tasting flight

Taste this against three others Cherry picks.

Brew a set side-by-side. Cherry varies the picks along axes that pair with this lot; origin, process, roast, or producer; so you learn the difference, not just drink four good cups.

Build the flight

Buyer reviews · this coffee

4.7/ 5· 19 reviews on Gotham Coffee Roasters’s product page
via judgeme

Aggregate of star ratings buyers left on this lot’s page on Gotham Coffee Roasters’s storefront. Cherrybook stores the average + count, not the individual reviews; tap through to read what buyers wrote.

Read all 19 reviews on Gotham Coffee Roasters →Last refreshed Jul 13, 2026

About Gotham Coffee Roasters

Community reputation · Reddit

Well-regarded· sentiment 75/100

There is insufficient information in the provided threads to form a reputation for Gotham Coffee Roasters. The roaster is mentioned only once in a passing comment identifying a user as a "Fellow New Yorker," but there is no discussion regarding the quality of their coffee, their roasting style, or customer service.

insufficient datano product feedbackmention only
Threads cited (2)

Press · Sprudge

← Back to browse

Gotham Coffee Roasters

$1.70/oz· $12/bag

Buy →