79Expect Spice, Chocolate, and Nutty from this washed / wet polished.
Lam Dong, VN · Washed / Wet Polished
Roaster
Coverage is below 50%. Most of this roaster’s lots are scored off roaster-level signals (Reddit + YouTube) without per-lot SCA grades, Coffee Review entries, or published buyer reviews. With limited signal, scores are also pulled toward a neutral 50 baseline by the Cherry’s Index methodology, so lots can read flatter than the actual cup quality differences between them. The avg Cherry’s Index reflects general reputation more than per-lot quality.
Roaster signals
Apply to every lot from this roaster.
Per-lot signals (averaged)
Vary across lots; averaged over 17 in-stock lots.
Bonuses earned (per lot)
Base components are renormalized over whatever signals are available for each lot. SCA + Coffee Review are capped at 40% combined to keep the cupping story from dominating. Bonuses (accolades, awards, editorial coverage) and freshness decay are applied on top.
Community reputation · Reddit
Well-regarded· sentiment 75/100
There is insufficient information in the provided threads to form a reputation for Gotham Coffee Roasters. The roaster is mentioned only once in a passing comment identifying a user as a "Fellow New Yorker," but there is no discussion regarding the quality of their coffee, their roasting style, or customer service.
Press · Sprudge
Created by New Gotham Coffee Community, #CoffeeAyudo starts Saturday, International Coffee Day.
Not really bath salts, that’s just for attention.
Flagship cafe
Retail location
New York, NY
Open in maps →Seed-city fallback applied (New York, NY); the website didn't expose a specific flagship address. LLM-finder notes: The website mentions they are 'on the road' and have an 'Events Calendar', but provides no physical retail address or headquarters location.
The catalog
79Expect Spice, Chocolate, and Nutty from this washed / wet polished.
Lam Dong, VN · Washed / Wet Polished
76Roaster flags Hazelnut, Chocolate, and Earthy Tones in the cup.
ID
76Think Smokey, Earthy, and Woody.
75Roaster flags Zingy, Balanced, and Chocolate in the cup.
72Think Mild, Smooth, and Chocolate.
Not ratedExpect Caramel, Chocolate, and Blackcurrant Acidity from this washed.
KE · Washed
Not ratedCupping notes point toward Apple, Vanilla, and Caramel.
CO
Not ratedExpect Citrus, Lemon, and Sweet Hazelnut from this washed.
CO · Washed
Not ratedFruity, Wine, and Mango on a natural build.
Djimma, ET · Natural
Not ratedExpect Sweet Butterscotch, Chocolate, and Honey from this washed.
Jinotega, NI · Washed
Not ratedExpect Cocoa, Creamy, and Nutty from this natural.
BR · Natural
Not ratedWashed lot with Nutty, Toffee, and Chocolate in the cup.
HN · Washed
Not ratedCitrus, Stone Fruits, and Floral Tones on a washed build.
KE · Washed
Not ratedWashed lot with Chocolate, Almond, and Citrus in the cup.
CR · Washed
Not ratedChocolate, Fruity, and Pomegranate on a washed build.
Cajamarca, PE · Washed
Not ratedExpect Maple Syrup Sweetness, Gentle Citrus Zing, and Silky Milk Chocolate Finish from this washed.
GT · Washed
Not ratedExpect Smoky, Earthy, and Malty Sweetness from this experimental.
Malabar Coast, IN · Experimental
Not ratedWashed lot with Citrus, Red Apple, and Floral in the cup.
Son La, VN · Washed
For roasters
Cherrybook runs a monthly Roaster Spotlight Series featuring one roaster with an editorial piece and a giveaway. Interested in being featured? See the format or email josh@cherrybookcoffee.com.