Skip to content
Cherrybook.
Stone Street Coffee

Brooklyn Roast - 250th Anniversary Edition

Medium★ 4.5 (4)· not counted

Cherrybook Index

42sparse

Evidence-of-quality score, not a cup score. Sparse signal: 2 of 7 signals on file. Methodology

Price position

$1.19/oz$18.99 for 1.0 lb

Typical band for this profile $0.99 to $1.88 (process unlisted single-origin lots (variety unlisted, retail bags); USD listings; medium roast in stock). Where it sits

Buyers

★ 4.5from 4 on-shop ratings · not counted in the Index

Catalog summary

This lot, not yet indexed (2 of 7 signals on file) and priced inside the typical band for its listed profile.

Based on the listing and catalog evidence

Price and availability set by the roaster.

Save at Stone Street CoffeeSave 10%Free shipping over $35Rewards program

Cherrybook last checked this listing today.

Roaster’s notes

citrus · honey · cocoa

  • Citrus
  • Cocoa and nut
  • Sugar and spice
Open the flavor wheel

Mapped from the roaster’s tasting notes to the SCA flavor wheel; Cherrybook’s interpretation of the stated notes, not the roaster’s own categorization.

Brooklyn Roast - 250th Anniversary Edition by Stone Street Coffee
Origin
—
Producer
—
Farm / Co-op
—
Process
—
Altitude
—
Varietals
—
Harvest
—
Weight
1.0 lb
Bag price
$18.99
Price / oz
$1.19/oz
Brew
—

from the roaster’s storeread by Cherrybook from the listing“estimated” below = inferred, not stated

Price contextmodeled

A modeled range and current prices for comparable listings.

$1.19/oz

typically $0.99 to $1.88

Where it sits

137 process unlisted single-origin lots (variety unlisted, retail bags); USD listings; medium roast in stock

typical band this lot

Limited listing details: 5th percentile of 137 process unlisted single-origin lots (variety unlisted, retail bags); USD listings; medium roast in stock right now.

Some variety, process or origin details are missing. This comparison does not qualify the coffee for a value recommendation.

What moves this price

cheaper×1.00pricier
  • Roaster brand and sourcing×0.77
  • Origin not listed×0.93
  • Variety not listed×0.96
  • Altitude not listed×0.97

At 454 g, this bag runs about 6% less per ounce than a typical 288 g bag; that is pack size, not the coffee.

How this estimate works

A statistical model, refit weekly across the in-stock catalog, estimates what a coffee with these listed attributes typically sells for per ounce. Each multiplier compares one trait against the average lot in this market; the roaster line covers brand and sourcing together, which this model cannot separate. Bag size is shown separately, priced at the rate observed across sizes of the same coffee, because it says nothing about the coffee itself. The distribution counts every in-stock listing in the comparison group, with at least 15 listings from three roasters and no roaster supplying more than 60% of it. Decaf, blends, variety segments, processing families and bag formats stay separate. Origin, roast and selling currency can broaden as the group label indicates. Prices are converted to USD per ounce; shipping and differences in tax treatment are not adjusted. The model reads listed attributes only: the quality of the specific lot in the bag is not observable, so a price above the typical band is not evidence of overpricing.

Some listing details are missing or have limited model coverage, so the typical band shown is wider than usual.

Not listed by the roaster: origin, process, variety, altitude

Cherrybook Index (CBI)

Evidence-of-quality score, not a cup score. Methodology

42

Sparse signal

Confidence2 of 7 signals on file

Score is heavily shrunk toward 50; treat as a placeholder until more sources arrive.

How confidence affects the score

Coverage measures signal availability, not cup quality. This coffee has 23% of the signal universe on file. Missing sources are dropped, remaining weights are renormalized, and the result is shrunk toward a neutral 50 baseline by 43% so one thin signal cannot carry the score on its own.

The math on file: renormalized base 41.9 shrunk to 45.4 + bonuses = 42.

Missing: SCA grade, Coffee Review, YouTube reviews, On-shop ratings, Cherrybook ratings

  • Reddit sentiment
    Sentiment across specialty-coffee discussion
    48/ 78% weight
  • Roaster transparency
    Producer / farm / lot disclosure depth
    20/ 22% weight

Bonuses applied

  • Stale-stock demotion
    This lot has been listed in stock for an extended time; specialty coffee freshness degrades over weeks
    +-4

Sensory profileestimated

Acidity
3
Body
3
Sweetness
4
Balance
4
Clean
4

Comps & alternatives

Tasting flight

Compare this with three more lots selected from the catalog.

Brew a set side-by-side. The picks vary along axes that pair with this lot; origin, process, roast, or producer; so you learn the difference, not just drink four good cups.

Build the flight

On-shop ratings · this coffee

4.5/ 5· 4 public ratings on Stone Street Coffee’s product page
via judgeme

Public aggregate shown on this lot’s page on Stone Street Coffee’s storefront. Cherrybook stores the average and count, plus a small set of recent identity-free excerpts when the provider makes them available.

Recent third-party buyer comments

Newest public excerpts
Judge.me5.0 / 5
Delicious Coffee
“I really enjoyed this coffee. Very delicious”
Verified buyer
Judge.me4.0 / 5
Morning Jolt
“Brooklyn Roast has a nice "strong" flavor. I mix it with either a Chocolate-flavored and/or a Mild Blend coffee to smooth it out!”
Verified buyer
Judge.me4.0 / 5
“The Limited Brooklyn Roast blend has a very earthy blue-collar taste.”
Verified buyer

These are short excerpts from third-party buyer reviews published on this product page. Storefronts may moderate reviews, and verification or incentive labels appear only when the provider supplies them. Their ratings are already represented in the aggregate above and are not counted again in Cherrybook Index.

How ratings count toward the Index

To count toward Cherrybook Index, an aggregate must come from a supported source, match this product, include at least 5 ratings, and have been refreshed within 90 days. Its weight is 12% for 5–24 ratings, 15% for 25–99, or 18% for 100 or more. Higher tiers require another base signal; a ratings-only lot stays at 12%.

View the product and its ratings on Stone Street Coffee →Not currently counted in Cherrybook Index · Refreshed Sep 27, 2026

About Stone Street Coffee

Community reputation · Reddit

Polarizing· sentiment 48/100

Two independent Reddit posts give limited, mixed feedback on Stone Street Coffee's cold-brew products. One home brewer said their best batch with Stone Street beans still lacked the bold, rounded flavor they wanted. Another struggled with Chocolate Indulgence and asked about higher-quality alternatives.

home cold-brew dialingChocolate Indulgence comparison
Threads cited (2)
  • r/Coffee · 6↑ · Cold brew help please...

    ...en messing around with cold brew recipes... I really love the chocolatey smooth flavor many cafe cold brews have. I haven’t been able to achieve that. I have been using Stone Street cold brew beans. I grind it coarsely using java press manual grinder on course setting. Last time I steeped for 24 hours (room temp) wi

  • r/Coffee · 6↑ · Cold brew newbie looking for recipes

    Hey! I recently bought the Hario Mizudashi cold brew coffee pot and the Stone Street chocolate indulgence ground coffee. I'm a coffee newbie, who, like many white girls before me, is very tired of spending money on iced mochas and would much rather just make my own. I've had a chocolate cold brew from a local coffee sh

On YouTube

Meet the roaster on camera

5 videos

About the roasterInterview

The Subscription Bet That Changed Everything | Benjamin Elmalek, Stone Street Coffee

Rewind · 11K views on YouTube

Watch on YouTube

This video covers Stone Street Coffee; it is general roaster coverage.

Cherrybook summary of the video

This interview features Benjamin Elmalek, the Chief Digital Officer of Stone Street Coffee. He discusses the company's roasting operations in Brooklyn and Mexico City, their diverse business model, and the pivotal role that customer-focused e-commerce and subscription services played in their growth.

Inside this video

From Rewind:

“We sell coffee in the US and Mexico. We have a roasting facility in Brooklyn, we have a roasting facility in Mexico City as well.”
“We really wanted to bring those stories to life and share with you how they've backed up to level up.”

Explore the videos

Videos by their credited creators. Playing a video connects to YouTube. Privacy

Stone Street Coffee

$1.19/oz· $18.99 a bag

Buy →