Medium
Shop 4.9 (137)
66CBI
$1.56/oz
Typical $1.07 to $2.04/oz
Limited comparison
Roaster · Brooklyn, NY
Stone Street Coffee
On YouTube
Meet the roaster on camera
About the roasterInterview
The Subscription Bet That Changed Everything | Benjamin Elmalek, Stone Street Coffee
Rewind · 11K views on YouTube
Watch on YouTubeCherrybook summary of the video
This interview features Benjamin Elmalek, the Chief Digital Officer of Stone Street Coffee. He discusses the company's roasting operations in Brooklyn and Mexico City, their diverse business model, and the pivotal role that customer-focused e-commerce and subscription services played in their growth.
Inside this video
From Rewind:
“We sell coffee in the US and Mexico. We have a roasting facility in Brooklyn, we have a roasting facility in Mexico City as well.”
“We really wanted to bring those stories to life and share with you how they've backed up to level up.”
Explore the videos
Videos by their credited creators. Playing a video connects to YouTube. Privacy
The roaster
44 lots in stock, mostly Ethiopia, Indonesia and Colombia.
- In stock
- 44
- House Index · limited data
- 54
- Freshness
- Roast cadence not disclosed
- Save at Stone Street Coffee
- Save 10%Free shipping over $35Rewards program
OriginsEthiopiaIndonesiaColombiaBrazilNicaraguaGuatemala
Roaster at a glance
- Tracked since
- April 2026100 lots seen; 44 in stock now
- Origins
- 12 countriesEthiopia, Nicaragua, Brazil
- Process mix
- Other 82% · Washed 14% · Natural 5%
- Price position
- 10% above what its profiles predictMedian of 5 in-stock lots against the price model
- Sourcing
- 9% of lots name the producer or farm4 of 44
- Buyer stars
- 4.9 out of 51599 reviews across 37 lots, from the roaster's own store
- Coverage
- 6 reviewer videos · 1 editorial mention · 2 Reddit threadsVideos and articles about the roaster, not by it
- Their channels
- Instagram ↗Facebook ↗Linked from their own site
- Merch
- 7 items in stock
How Cherrybook Index is calculatedavg coverage 32% · limited data
Coverage is below 50%. Available roaster-level evidence comes from Reddit. Per-lot evidence from SCA grades, Coffee Review entries, and public on-shop product ratings is limited across the catalog. With limited signal, scores are also pulled toward a neutral 50 baseline by the Cherrybook Index methodology, so lots can read flatter than the actual cup quality differences between them. The average Cherrybook Index therefore leans more heavily on roaster-level reputation than per-lot quality.
Roaster signals
Apply to every lot from this roaster.
- Reddit48/100weight 18%
- YouTube—weight 10%
Per-lot signals (averaged)
Vary across lots; averaged over 44 in-stock lots.
- SCA gradenot on file · weight 25%
- Coffee Reviewnot on file · weight 20%
- On-shop ratings96.9/10030/44 lots · weight 12–18% · avg 14.7%
- Cherrybook reader ratingsnot on file · weight 30%
- Transparency28/10032/44 lots · weight 5%
Bonuses earned (per lot)
- stale decay44/44
Base components are renormalized over whatever signals are available for each lot. SCA + Coffee Review are capped at 40% combined to keep the cupping story from dominating. Bonuses (accolades, awards, editorial coverage) and freshness decay are applied on top.
The catalog
44 in stock · 4 archived
Knee Buckling Espresso
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Dark
Shop 4.9 (128)
66CBI
$1.25/oz
Typical $0.90 to $1.72/oz
Limited comparison
The Perfect Espresso
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
Shop 4.8 (152)
65CBI
$1.25/oz
Typical $0.95 to $1.81/oz
Limited comparison
Ethiopian Yirgacheffe
Expect Lemon, Chocolate, and Floral from this washed lot.
Yirgacheffe, ET · Washed
LightLemonChocolateFloral
Shop 4.9 (135)
64CBI
$1.50/oz
Typical $1.06 to $2.02/oz
Limited comparison
House Blend
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
Shop 5.0 (68)
62CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $0.95 to $1.81/oz
Limited comparison
Rainforest Espresso
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
Shop 5.0 (43)
62CBI
$1.25/oz
Typical $0.92 to $1.76/oz
Limited comparison
European Fancy Decaf
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
Shop 4.9 (44)
62CBI
$1.56/oz
Typical $0.92 to $1.76/oz
Limited comparison
Dark
Shop 4.9 (49)
62CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $0.89 to $1.69/oz
Limited comparison
LightSpicePlumRaspberry
Shop 4.9 (39)
61CBI
$1.23/oz
Typical $1.15 to $2.18/oz
Limited comparison
Espresso Decaffeinato
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
Shop 4.8 (49)
61CBI
$1.56/oz
Typical $0.95 to $1.81/oz
Limited comparison
Dark Roast Blend
Think Chocolatey.
DarkChocolate
Shop 4.9 (138)
61CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $0.90 to $1.72/oz
Limited comparison
LightLimeDark Chocolate
Shop 4.9 (32)
60CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $1.17 to $1.87/oz
Medium-DarkGrapeCitrusCaramel
Shop 4.9 (35)
60CBI
$1.37/oz
Typical $1.14 to $2.18/oz
Limited comparison
MediumApricotTropical Fruit
Shop 4.9 (33)
60CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $1.05 to $2.00/oz
Limited comparison
DarkChocolateStone FruitTropical Fruit
Shop 4.9 (51)
60CBI
$1.56/oz
Typical $1.04 to $1.97/oz
Limited comparison
DarkChocolateTobaccoSpice
Shop 4.9 (96)
60CBI
$1.56/oz
Typical $1.07 to $2.03/oz
Limited comparison
Light
Shop 5.0 (6)
59CBI
$2.50/oz
Typical $1.31 to $2.09/oz
Broad comparison
LightBlueberryChocolateCaramel
Shop 4.9 (55)
59CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $1.21 to $2.31/oz
Limited comparison
Medium
Shop 4.9 (14)
59CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $1.12 to $2.14/oz
Limited comparison
Wall Street Blend
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
Shop 4.9 (13)
59CBI
$1.25/oz
Typical $0.95 to $1.81/oz
Limited comparison
LightCaramelChocolateTropical Fruit+1
Shop 4.7 (34)
58CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $1.13 to $2.16/oz
Limited comparison
LightMilk ChocolateCitrus
Shop 4.8 (32)
58CBI
$1.25/oz
Typical $1.15 to $2.20/oz
Limited comparison
Mayan Water Half-Caff
Cupping notes point toward Earthy.
Medium
Shop 4.9 (47)
57CBI
$1.56/oz
Typical $0.97 to $1.85/oz
Limited comparison
Medium-Dark
Shop 4.7 (11)
57CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $1.00 to $1.90/oz
Limited comparison
Miscela Privata — Espresso
Cupping notes point toward Chocolate.
DarkChocolate
Shop 4.9 (40)
57CBI
$1.25/oz
Typical $0.98 to $1.87/oz
Limited comparison
Mayan Water Decaf
Cupping notes point toward Earthy Notes.
Medium
Shop 4.9 (65)
57CBI
$1.56/oz
Typical $0.95 to $1.81/oz
Limited comparison
Medium-LightCocoaCitrus
Shop 5.0 (7)
55CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $1.00 to $1.90/oz
Limited comparison
Nicaragua Pacamara — Reserve Series
Natural lot with Mango, Passionfruit, and Brown Sugar in the cup.
Nicaragua · Natural
LightMangoPassion FruitBrown Sugar+1
Shop 4.4 (5)
55CBI
$2.50/oz
Typical $1.42 to $2.27/oz
Broad comparison
Real World
Roaster flags Earthy and Fruity in the cup.
DarkFruity
Shop 5.0 (16)
54CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $0.98 to $1.87/oz
Limited comparison
MediumTropical FruitCocoa
Shop 4.7 (12)
53CBI
$1.34/oz
Typical $1.02 to $1.95/oz
Limited comparison
JasmineBergamotPeach
45CBI
$6.51/oz
Typical $4.83 to $9.20/oz
DarkPassion FruitDark ChocolateSpice
44CBI
$2.81/oz
Typical $1.67 to $3.18/oz
Nicaragua Geisha — Reserve Series
Washed lot with Floral Aroma and Tea Like Body in the cup.
Nicaragua · Washed
LightFloralTea Like
44CBI
$3.81/oz
Typical $2.33 to $3.72/oz
Broad comparison
Nicaragua Java — Reserve Series
Bright Citrus, Jasmine, and Milk Chocolate on a washed lot.
Nicaragua · Washed
LightCitrusJasmineMilk Chocolate+1
44CBI
$3.41/oz
Typical $1.31 to $2.09/oz
Broad comparison
DarkChocolateStone FruitTropical Fruit
42CBI
$1.43/oz
LightMilk ChocolateCitrusOverall Sweet
42CBI
$1.11/oz
LightCaramelChocolateTropical Fruit+1
42CBI
$1.07/oz
Anniversary Heritage Blend — Medium Roast
Roaster flags Smooth, Aromatic, and Gently Sweet in the cup.
MediumOverall Sweet
40CBI
$1.37/oz
Typical $0.95 to $1.81/oz
Limited comparison
Dark Blend
Roaster flags Sweet Tobacco, Fruit, and Cocoa in the cup.
Medium-DarkPipe TobaccoOther FruitCocoa
40CBI
$1.07/oz
MediumTropical FruitCocoa
40CBI
$1.19/oz
MediumChocolateCitrus
40CBI
$1.07/oz
The 1776 Espresso — Espresso
Cupping notes point toward Chocolate, Toasted Nut, and Balanced Finish.
MediumChocolateNutty
40CBI
$1.37/oz
Typical $0.95 to $1.81/oz
Limited comparison
Brooklyn Roast — 250th Anniversary Edition
Roaster flags Citrus, Honey, and Cocoa in the cup.
MediumCitrusHoneyCocoa
40CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $1.00 to $1.91/oz
Limited comparison
Wall Street Espresso — Espresso
Roaster flags Creamy and Balanced in the cup.
MediumCaramel
39CBI
$1.19/oz
Typical $0.95 to $1.81/oz
Limited comparison
Also available · subscriptions, sample packs, gear
Mayan Water Half-Caff - 3 Month Gift Subscription
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
44CBI
$5.75/oz
The Perfect Espresso - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
44CBI
$19.36/oz
Rainforest Espresso - 3 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
44CBI
$4.84/oz
Brooklyn Roast - 6 Month Gift Subscription
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
44CBI
$9.68/oz
Brooklyn Roast
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
44CBI
$1.25/oz
House Blend — Medium Roast
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
44CBI
$0.78/oz
House Blend - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
44CBI
$18.36/oz
Nicaragua Reserve Bundle
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
44CBI
$2.03/oz
The Perfect Espresso - 3 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Dark
44CBI
$4.84/oz
Espresso Decaffeinato - 6 Month Gift Subscription
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
44CBI
$11.55/oz
Brooklyn Roast - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
44CBI
$19.36/oz
Wall Street Blend - 3 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Dark
44CBI
$4.84/oz
Espresso Decaffeinato - 3 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
44CBI
$5.75/oz
Brooklyn Roast - 3 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
44CBI
$4.84/oz
Main Street — 250th Anniversary Edition
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
44CBI
$1.19/oz
The Perfect Espresso - 6 Month Gift Subscription
Taste data is still sparse; open the detail page before judging this lot.
Medium
44CBI
$9.68/oz
Wall Street Blend - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Dark
44CBI
$19.36/oz
Espresso Decaffeinato - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Medium
44CBI
$23.07/oz
Sumatra Mandheling - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Roaster flags Chocolate, Cedar, and Sweet Tobacco in the cup.
Sumatra, ID
DarkChocolateTobaccoSpice
42CBI
$23.07/oz
DarkChocolateTobaccoSpice
42CBI
$11.55/oz
DarkChocolatePipe TobaccoSpice
41CBI
$5.75/oz
Colombian Supremo - 6 Month Gift Subscription
Roaster flags Caramel and Chocolate in the cup.
Huila, CO
LightCaramelChocolate
40CBI
$9.18/oz
Colombian Supremo - 3 Month Gift Subscription
Roaster flags Caramel and Chocolate in the cup.
Huila, CO
LightCaramelChocolate
40CBI
$4.56/oz
Colombian Supremo - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Cupping notes point toward Caramel and Chocolate.
Colombia
LightCaramelChocolate
40CBI
$18.36/oz
House Blend - 6 Month Gift Subscription
Cupping notes point toward Smoky Finish.
MediumSmoky
39CBI
$9.18/oz
Mayan Water Half-Caff - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Cupping notes point toward Earthy.
Medium
39CBI
$23.07/oz
Rainforest Espresso - 6 Month Gift Subscription
Roaster flags Creamy and Smooth in the cup.
Medium
39CBI
$9.68/oz
Rainforest Espresso - 12 Month Gift Subscription
Cupping notes point toward Creamy and Smooth.
Medium
39CBI
$19.36/oz
Mayan Water Half-Caff - 6 Month Gift Subscription
Cupping notes point toward Earthy.
Medium
39CBI
$11.55/oz
Archived (4)
Medium-LightOrangeLemonBlack Tea
49CBI
$1.44/oz
Out of stock
MediumDried FruitCaramelSpice
47CBI
$1.56/oz
Out of stock
MediumBrown SugarOrangeLemon
46CBI
$1.56/oz
Out of stock
Medium-DarkBlueberryBlackberry
45CBI
$1.34/oz
Out of stock
Community reputation · Reddit
Polarizing· sentiment 48/100
Two independent Reddit posts give limited, mixed feedback on Stone Street Coffee's cold-brew products. One home brewer said their best batch with Stone Street beans still lacked the bold, rounded flavor they wanted. Another struggled with Chocolate Indulgence and asked about higher-quality alternatives.
home cold-brew dialingChocolate Indulgence comparison
Threads cited (2)
- r/Coffee · 6↑ · Cold brew help please...
...en messing around with cold brew recipes... I really love the chocolatey smooth flavor many cafe cold brews have. I haven’t been able to achieve that. I have been using Stone Street cold brew beans. I grind it coarsely using java press manual grinder on course setting. Last time I steeped for 24 hours (room temp) wi
- r/Coffee · 6↑ · Cold brew newbie looking for recipes
Hey! I recently bought the Hario Mizudashi cold brew coffee pot and the Stone Street chocolate indulgence ground coffee. I'm a coffee newbie, who, like many white girls before me, is very tired of spending money on iced mochas and would much rather just make my own. I've had a chocolate cold brew from a local coffee sh
Flagship cafe
Retail location
Brooklyn, NY
Open in maps →Roaster in Brooklyn with wholesale and online operations; no cafe mentioned in the text.
For roasters
Cherrybook runs a monthly Roaster Spotlight Series featuring one roaster with an editorial piece and a giveaway. Interested in being featured? See the format or email josh@cherrybookcoffee.com.