Colombian 5lb
MediumSCA cup 93.0★ 4.9 (101)
Cherrybook Index
69Noted
Evidence-of-quality score, not a cup score. Confident: 3 of 7 signals on file. Methodology
Price position
$0.91/oz$73.95 for 5.1 lb
Price position appears once the price model has scored this lot.
Buyers
★ 4.9from 101 on-shop ratings
Catalog summary
A lot from Colombia, indexed 69 on confident evidence.
Based on the listing and catalog evidence
Price and availability set by the roaster.
Save at Mystic Monk CoffeeFree shipping over $49
Cherrybook last checked this listing 6 days ago.
Roaster’s notes
dark chocolate · red apple · caramel · cedar · orange blossom
- Fruit
- Floral
- Cocoa and nut
- Sugar and spice
Open the flavor wheel
Mapped from the roaster’s tasting notes to the SCA flavor wheel; Cherrybook’s interpretation of the stated notes, not the roaster’s own categorization.
- Origin
- Colombia
- Producer
- —
- Farm / Co-op
- —
- Process
- —
- Altitude
- —
- Varietals
- —
- Harvest
- —
- Weight
- 5.1 lb
- Bag price
- $73.95
- Price / oz
- $0.91/oz
- Brew
- —
from the roaster’s storeread by Cherrybook from the listing“estimated” below = inferred, not stated
Cherrybook Index (CBI)
Evidence-of-quality score, not a cup score. Methodology
69
Noted
Confident
Confidence3 of 7 signals on file
Enough independent signal to score at face value; no shrinkage applied.
How confidence affects the score
Coverage measures signal availability, not cup quality. This coffee has 48% of the signal universe on file. Missing sources are dropped, remaining weights are renormalized, and the result is shrunk toward a neutral 50 baseline by 0% so one thin signal cannot carry the score on its own.
Missing: Coffee Review, Reddit sentiment, YouTube reviews, Cherrybook ratings
- 97/ 38% weightOn-shop ratingsPublic product-page ratings; current supported sources only
- 65/ 52% weightSCA gradeRoaster-published cupping score
- 35/ 10% weightRoaster transparencyProducer / farm / lot disclosure depth
Bonuses applied
- +-5Stale-stock demotionThis lot has been listed in stock for an extended time; specialty coffee freshness degrades over weeks
Base weighted score: 73.7 + bonuses = 69
Comps & alternatives
Tasting flight
Compare this with three more lots selected from the catalog.
Brew a set side-by-side. The picks vary along axes that pair with this lot; origin, process, roast, or producer; so you learn the difference, not just drink four good cups.
Reference · About the varietal & origin
On-shop ratings · this coffee
4.9/ 5· 101 public ratings on Mystic Monk Coffee’s product page
via judgemePublic aggregate shown on this lot’s page on Mystic Monk Coffee’s storefront. Cherrybook stores the average and count, plus a small set of recent identity-free excerpts when the provider makes them available.
How ratings count toward the Index
To count toward Cherrybook Index, an aggregate must come from a supported source, match this product, include at least 5 ratings, and have been refreshed within 90 days. Its weight is 12% for 5–24 ratings, 15% for 25–99, or 18% for 100 or more. Higher tiers require another base signal; a ratings-only lot stays at 12%.
View the product and its ratings on Mystic Monk Coffee →Count-adjusted Cherrybook Index weight 18% · Refreshed Sep 20, 2026
About Mystic Monk Coffee
On YouTube
Meet the roaster on camera
About the roasterBrand film
Mystic Monk Coffee: Roasting Your Coffee | Carmelite Monks of Wyoming
Carmelite Monks of Wyoming · 65K views on YouTube
Watch on YouTubeThis video covers Mystic Monk Coffee; it is general roaster coverage.
Cherrybook summary of the video
This video provides a look into the roasting process at Mystic Monk Coffee. It highlights their commitment to small batch roasting and the connection between their coffee production and the monastic life of the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming.
Inside this video
From Carmelite Monks of Wyoming:
“We roast in small batches to ensure the highest quality and freshness in every cup.”
“Our goal is to provide you with the finest coffee while supporting our life of prayer and work.”
Explore the videos
Videos by their credited creators. Playing a video connects to YouTube. Privacy