74Roaster flags Rum, Pecan, and Cream in the cup.
Medium-LightPecanRumCaramelized+2
Buyer 5.0 (841)
$1.10/oz
Roaster
Mystic Monk Coffee
Meeteetse, WYwww.mysticmonkcoffee.com ↗
- Coffees in catalog
- 15
- Also available
- 18
- Avg Cherry's Index
- 69.1
- Reddit sentiment
- 70/100
FreshnessRoast cadence not disclosed
OriginsETCORWIDGTPG
How Cherry’s Index is calculatedavg coverage 68%
Roaster signals
Apply to every lot from this roaster.
- Reddit70/100weight 18%
- YouTube75/100weight 10%
Per-lot signals (averaged)
Vary across lots; averaged over 15 in-stock lots.
- SCA grade58.3/1009/15 lots · weight 25%
- Coffee Review58.8/1008/15 lots · weight 20%
- Buyer reviews97.6/10015/15 lots · weight 12%
- Cherrybook reader ratingsnot on file · weight 5%
- Transparency31.7/10015/15 lots · weight 5%
Bonuses earned (per lot)
- stale decay14/15
Base components are renormalized over whatever signals are available for each lot. SCA + Coffee Review are capped at 40% combined to keep the cupping story from dominating. Bonuses (accolades, awards, editorial coverage) and freshness decay are applied on top.
Community reputation · Reddit
Well-regarded· sentiment 70/100
Mystic Monk Coffee is mentioned in the context of curiosity and exploration, with users expressing interest in their status as a monastery-based roaster. While there is no consensus or deep review of their specific flavor profiles, they are viewed as a legitimate option for those looking to venture into online coffee subscriptions. The discussions surrounding them are neutral to inquisitive, with no patterns of negative feedback regarding their quality or service.
monastery-based roastingniche interestonline coffee subscription optioncuriosity-driven exploration
On YouTube
5 videos · 72k combined views
Outside coverage focuses on the unique origin of Mystic Monk Coffee as a project of the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming. Reviewers highlight the brand's rapid growth and its ability to bridge the gap between Catholic and secular consumer bases. The coverage emphasizes that the roasting process is deeply integrated with the monks' daily life of prayer and work.
Monastic production modelRapid brand expansionCross-demographic appealSmall batch roasting focusIntegration of work and prayer
From Mystic Monk Coffee
- 4k views
Flavored Coffee | Mystic Monk Coffee by Carmelite Monks of Wyoming
Mystic Monk Coffee
- 2k views
Cowboy Blend | Mystic Monk Coffee by Carmelite Monks of Wyoming
Mystic Monk Coffee
- 1k views
Paradiso Blend | Mystic Monk Coffee by Carmelite Monks of Wyoming
Mystic Monk Coffee
- 1k views
Ethiopian | Mystic Monk Coffee by Carmelite Monks of Wyoming
Mystic Monk Coffee
Flagship cafe
Mystic Monk Coffee HQ
1079 Meeteetse Creek Rd, Meeteetse, WY
Open in maps →The website lists a physical address for contact purposes but does not indicate a retail cafe or storefront open to the public.
The catalog
15 in stock · 25 archived
74
74Roaster flags Bittersweet Dark Chocolate, Savory Nuttiness, and Burnt Sugar in the cup.
Medium-DarkDark ChocolateNuttyBurnt Sugar
Buyer 4.9 (446)
$1.10/oz
73Expect Jasmine, Lemon Curd, and Ripe Blueberry from this natural.
ET · Natural
Medium-LightFloralJasmineLemon+4
SCA 94.0
$1.17/oz
73Cupping notes point toward Caramel and Spice.
ID
DarkCaramelizedPepper
Buyer 5.0 (469)
$1.10/oz
73Roaster flags Toffee, Dark Chocolate, and Buttery Caramel in the cup.
MediumChocolateToffeeCaramel
Buyer 4.9 (168)
$1.10/oz
73Roaster flags Dark Chocolate, Nutty, and Charred Wood in the cup.
DarkDark ChocolateNuttySmoky
Buyer 4.9 (71)
$1.10/oz
70Think Dark Chocolate, Red Apple, and Caramel.
CO
MediumDark ChocolateAppleCaramelized+3
SCA 93.0
$1.10/oz
69Cupping notes point toward Apricot, Raisin, and Milk Chocolate.
MediumApricotRaisinMilk Chocolate+7
SCA 93.0
$1.10/oz
69Cupping notes point toward Peanut Butter, Brown Sugar, and Vanilla.
MediumPeanut ButterBrown SugarVanilla+9
Buyer 4.9 (1444)
$1.32/oz
67Think Nutty, Dark Chocolate, and Bittersweet Chocolate.
DarkNuttyChocolatePipe Tobacco+4
SCA 91.0
$1.17/oz
67Think Peach, Candied Orange, and Passion Fruit.
Medium-LightPeachOrangePassion Fruit+7
SCA 91.0
$1.25/oz
66Cupping notes point toward Dark Chocolate, Salted Caramel, and Scorched Cedar.
Medium-DarkDark ChocolateCaramelizedCedar+6
SCA 92.0
$1.10/oz
Not ratedRoaster flags Cocoa, Caramel, and Vanilla in the cup.
MediumCocoa PowderCaramelVanilla+8
SCA 91.0
$1.10/oz
Not ratedThink Chocolate Fudge, Scorched Cedar, and Roasted Hazelnut.
DarkChocolateMolassesSmoky+5
SCA 90.0
$1.10/oz
Not ratedCupping notes point toward Milk Chocolate, Roasted Almond, and Date.
MediumChocolateAlmondDate+1
SCA 90.0
$1.17/oz
Also available · subscriptions, sample packs, gear
74Roaster flags Peach, Candied Orange, and Passion Fruit in the cup.
RW
LightPeachOrangePassion Fruit+2
Buyer 4.9 (578)
$1.25/oz
74Cupping notes point toward Bittersweet Chocolate, Malt, and Charred Oak.
Medium-DarkDark ChocolateMaltSmoky+2
Buyer 5.0 (65)
$0.91/oz
73Cupping notes point toward Pecan Pralines, Rum, and Fresh Cream.
NuttyOther FruitOverall Sweet
Buyer 5.0 (100)
$0.91/oz
73Think Dark Chocolate, Baking Spice, and Woody.
DarkDark ChocolateSpiceWood
Buyer 5.0 (117)
$0.91/oz
73Think Smooth Caramel Essence, Brown Butter Notes, and Creamy, Dessert Like Finish.
MediumCaramelizedSweet Aromatics
Buyer 5.0 (551)
$1.10/oz
73Roaster flags Hazelnut, Vanilla, and Praline in the cup.
MediumHazelnutVanillaPraline
Buyer 4.9 (500)
$1.10/oz
72Think Roasted Hazelnut, Creamy, and Vanilla.
HazelnutVanilla
Buyer 4.9 (66)
$0.91/oz
71Roaster flags Dark Chocolate, Red Apple, and Caramel in the cup.
CO
MediumDark ChocolateAppleCaramelized+3
SCA 93.0
$0.91/oz
69Roaster flags Charred Cedar, Baking Chocolate, and Smoky in the cup.
DarkCocoaSmokyCaramelized
Buyer 5.0 (72)
$0.91/oz
69Cupping notes point toward Raisin, Apricot, and Milk Chocolate.
Medium-LightRaisinPeachChocolate+5
SCA 93.0
$0.91/oz
67
66Roaster flags Dark Chocolate, Salted Caramel, and Scorched Cedar in the cup.
Medium-DarkDark ChocolateCaramelizedBurnt+2
SCA 92.0
$0.91/oz
66Cupping notes point toward Cocoa, Caramel, and Vanilla.
MediumCocoaCaramelizedVanilla+9
SCA 91.5
$0.91/oz
Not ratedNot much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Dark
Well-reviewed roaster
$0.92/oz
Not ratedThink Floral, Blueberry, and Citrus.
ET
Medium-LightFloralBlueberryCitrus+4
SCA 94.0
$0.95/oz
Not ratedRoaster flags Syrupy Crema, Caramel, and Dark Chocolate in the cup.
Medium-DarkCaramelizedChocolateCocoa+6
SCA 91.0
$0.91/oz
Not ratedCupping notes point toward Chocolate Fudge, Scorched Cedar, and Roasted Hazelnut.
Medium-DarkChocolateVanillaHazelnut+3
SCA 90.0
$0.91/oz
Not ratedRoaster flags Vanilla, Berry, and Chocolate in the cup.
VanillaBerryChocolate
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Archived (25)
73Cupping notes point toward Cinnamon, Bourbon, and White Chocolate.
CinnamonWhiskeyChocolate
Buyer 4.9 (642)
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
73Roaster flags Creamy White Chocolate Sweetness, Buttery Macadamia, and Tropical Fruit Hints in the cup.
White ChocolateMacadamiaTropical Fruit
Buyer 4.9 (141)
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
73Cupping notes point toward Cinnamon Spice, Brown Sugar, and Buttery Cake.
CinnamonBrown SugarHazelnut+1
Buyer 4.9 (323)
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
72Expect Stonefruit, Port, and Cacao from this honey.
Huila, CO · Honey
Medium-LightStone FruitWineyCocoa
Buyer 5.0 (15)
$1.20/oz
Out of stock
72Roaster flags Almond and Toffee in the cup.
AlmondToffee
Buyer 4.9 (220)
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
70Peach, Black Grape, and Black Tea on a anaerobic natural build.
Yirgacheffe, ET · Anaerobic Natural
Medium-LightPeachGrapeBlack Tea+7
SCA 94.0
$1.25/oz
Out of stock
67Think Persimmon, Baking Chocolate, and Nutmeg.
Medium-DarkPeachNutmegPepper+7
SCA 93.0
$1.25/oz
Out of stock
66Roaster flags Citrus, Passion Fruit, and Aromatic Wood in the cup.
Atitlan, GT
MediumCitrusPassion FruitWood+6
SCA 93.0
$1.20/oz
Out of stock
66Think Baker’s Chocolate, Molasses, and Ripe Peach.
Chimbu, PG
MediumCocoaMolassesPeach+4
SCA 93.0
$1.20/oz
Out of stock
66Cupping notes point toward Ripe Stone Fruit, Red Apple Acidity, and Hazelnut.
Boquete, PA
Medium-LightPeachMilk ChocolateHazelnut+7
SCA 93.0
$1.20/oz
Out of stock
66Think Floral, Chocolate, and Citrus.
MediumFloralChocolateCitrus+7
SCA 93.0
$1.25/oz
Out of stock
65Expect Grape Candy, Baking Chocolate, and Fresh Cut Oak from this anaerobic natural.
Yirgacheffe, ET · Anaerobic Natural
MediumGrapeChocolateOak+5
SCA 92.0
$1.25/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedCupping notes point toward Raisin, Apricot, and Milk Chocolate.
MediumRaisinApricotChocolate+2
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedThink Peppermint, Creamy Vanilla Undertones, and Minty Finish.
HerbVanillaOverall Sweet
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedThink Huckleberry, Sweet Blueberry, and Raspberry.
BlueberryRaspberry
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedRoaster flags Irish Cream Liqueur, Smooth Cream Liqueur Flavor, and Vanilla Bean Richness in the cup.
Overall SweetVanilla
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedThink Cinnamon, Bourbon, and White Chocolate.
CinnamonWhiskeyChocolate
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedCupping notes point toward Dark Chocolate, Pine, and Orange Zest.
Medium-DarkPeachChocolatePine+1
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedRoaster flags Charred Cedar, Vanilla, and Baking Spice in the cup.
Medium-DarkCharredVanillaBrown Spice+1
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedRoaster flags Cocoa, Caramel, and Vanilla in the cup.
Medium-DarkCocoaCaramelizedVanilla
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedCupping notes point toward Chocolate, Roasted Peanuts, and Caramel.
ChocolatePeanutCaramelized
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedRoaster flags Coconut Liqueur, Tropical Coconut, and Sweetness in the cup.
CoconutOverall Sweet
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedThink Banana, Creamy, and Tropical Rum.
Other FruitWhiskey
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedThink Blueberry Muffin.
BlueberryBaked Goods
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Not ratedThink Butterscotch and Creamy.
ButterscotchCreamy
Well-reviewed roaster
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
For roasters
Cherrybook runs a monthly Roaster Spotlight Series featuring one roaster with an editorial piece and a giveaway. Interested in being featured? See the format or email josh@cherrybookcoffee.com.