MediumMilk ChocolateHazelnutTangerine+1
SCA 94.0
73CBI
$1.61/oz
Typical $0.86 to $1.64/oz
Roaster · Cody, WY
Mystic Monk Coffee
On YouTube
Meet the roaster on camera
About the roasterBrand film
Mystic Monk Coffee: Roasting Your Coffee | Carmelite Monks of Wyoming
Carmelite Monks of Wyoming · 65K views on YouTube
Watch on YouTubeCherrybook summary of the video
This video provides a look into the roasting process at Mystic Monk Coffee. It highlights their commitment to small batch roasting and the connection between their coffee production and the monastic life of the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming.
Inside this video
From Carmelite Monks of Wyoming:
“We roast in small batches to ensure the highest quality and freshness in every cup.”
“Our goal is to provide you with the finest coffee while supporting our life of prayer and work.”
Explore the videos
Videos by their credited creators. Playing a video connects to YouTube. Privacy
The roaster
33 lots in stock, mostly Ethiopia, Colombia and Indonesia.
- In stock
- 33
- House Index · limited data
- 61
- Freshness
- Roast cadence not disclosed
- Save at Mystic Monk Coffee
- Free shipping over $49
OriginsEthiopiaColombiaIndonesiaKenyaHondurasGuatemala
Roaster at a glance
- Tracked since
- April 202684 lots seen; 33 in stock now
- Origins
- 4 countriesColombia, Ethiopia, Indonesia
- Process mix
- Other 82% · Natural 12% · Washed 3% · Honey 3%
- Sourcing
- 3% of lots name the producer or farm1 of 33
- Buyer stars
- 4.9 out of 510427 reviews across 29 lots, from the roaster's own store
- Coverage
- 6 reviewer videosVideos and articles about the roaster, not by it
- Where to find them
- Online only, Cody, WYMonastery roastery in Wyoming selling coffee online; no public cafe mentioned.
- Merch
- 4 items in stock
How Cherrybook Index is calculatedavg coverage 41% · limited data
Coverage is below 50%. No Reddit or YouTube roaster-level signal is on file. Per-lot evidence from SCA grades, Coffee Review entries, and public on-shop product ratings is limited across the catalog. With limited signal, scores are also pulled toward a neutral 50 baseline by the Cherrybook Index methodology, so lots can read flatter than the actual cup quality differences between them. The average Cherrybook Index therefore reflects the limited per-lot evidence plus the methodology's neutral baseline.
Roaster signals
Apply to every lot from this roaster.
- Reddit—weight 0%
- YouTube—weight 10%
Per-lot signals (averaged)
Vary across lots; averaged over 33 in-stock lots.
- SCA grade60/10016/33 lots · weight 25%
- Coffee Review57.5/10018/33 lots · weight 20%
- On-shop ratings98.4/10029/33 lots · weight 12–18% · avg 17%
- Cherrybook reader ratingsnot on file · weight 30%
- Transparency27.5/10032/33 lots · weight 5%
Bonuses earned (per lot)
- stale decay32/33
Base components are renormalized over whatever signals are available for each lot. SCA + Coffee Review are capped at 40% combined to keep the cupping story from dominating. Bonuses (accolades, awards, editorial coverage) and freshness decay are applied on top.
The catalog
33 in stock · 33 archived
Fair Trade Ethiopian Coffee
Expect Jasmine, Lemon Curd, and Ripe Blueberry from this natural lot.
Ethiopia · Natural
Medium-Light
SCA 94.0
70CBI
$1.17/oz
Typical $0.97 to $1.85/oz
Limited comparison
MediumCocoaAppleCaramel+1
SCA 93.0
69CBI
$0.91/oz
Super Monk Blend Extra Caffeinated Coffee
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Dark
SCA 91.0
68CBI
$1.17/oz
Typical $0.79 to $1.51/oz
Limited comparison
Paradiso Blend Coffee
Cupping notes point toward Hazelnut Like Nuttiness, Sweet Orange Zest, and Silky Milk Chocolate Finish.
DarkHazelnutOrangeMilk Chocolate+11
Shop 4.9 (1472)
67CBI
$1.32/oz
Typical $0.79 to $1.51/oz
Limited comparison
Breakfast Blend
Cupping notes point toward Raisin, Apricot, and Milk Chocolate.
MediumRaisinApricotMilk Chocolate+4
SCA 93.0
67CBI
$0.91/oz
Medium-LightDark ChocolateAppleCaramel+2
SCA 93.0
67CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.99 to $1.89/oz
Limited comparison
Breakfast Blend
Cupping notes point toward Apricot, Raisin, and Milk Chocolate.
Medium-Light
SCA 93.0
67CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.84 to $1.60/oz
Limited comparison
Espresso Blend
Roaster flags Charred Cedar, Baking Chocolate, and Smoky in the cup.
DarkChocolateSmoky
Shop 5.0 (73)
65CBI
$0.91/oz
DarkCaramelSpice
Shop 5.0 (483)
65CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.86 to $1.64/oz
Limited comparison
Mystic Monk Blend
Natural lot with Dark Chocolate, Salted Caramel, and Scorched Cedar in the cup.
Sumatra, ID · Natural
Medium-DarkDark ChocolateCaramelVanilla+2
SCA 92.0
65CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.88 to $1.67/oz
Limited comparison
Medium-DarkCocoaNutty
Shop 4.9 (458)
64CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.81 to $1.54/oz
Limited comparison
Royal Rum Pecan
Cupping notes point toward Pecan Pralines, Rum, and Fresh Cream.
PecanWhiskey
Shop 5.0 (101)
64CBI
$0.91/oz
Hermits Bold Blend
Think Dark Chocolate, Baking Spice, and Woody.
DarkDark ChocolateSpice
Shop 5.0 (126)
63CBI
$0.91/oz
Royal Rum Pecan
Roaster flags Rum, Pecan, and Cream in the cup.
Light
Shop 4.9 (855)
63CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.93 to $1.77/oz
Limited comparison
Hazelnut Coffee
Roaster flags Hazelnut, Vanilla, and Chocolate in the cup.
MediumHazelnutVanillaChocolate+1
Shop 4.9 (511)
63CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.86 to $1.63/oz
Limited comparison
Mystic Monk Blend
Roaster flags Dark Chocolate, Salted Caramel, and Scorched Cedar in the cup.
DarkDark ChocolateCaramelSmoky+2
SCA 92.0
62CBI
$0.91/oz
Caramel Flavored Coffee: Carmel Blend
Think Caramel and Brown Butter.
MediumCaramel
Shop 5.0 (566)
62CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.81 to $1.54/oz
Limited comparison
Cowboy Blend
Cupping notes point toward Cocoa, Caramel, and Vanilla.
MediumCocoaCaramelVanilla+7
SCA 91.0
61CBI
$0.91/oz
Cowboy Blend
Roaster flags Cocoa, Caramel, and Vanilla in the cup.
Medium-DarkCocoaCaramelVanilla+7
SCA 91.0
60CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.78 to $1.49/oz
Limited comparison
Medium
SCA 94.0
59CBI
$0.95/oz
Espresso Classico
Roaster flags Caramel, Dark Chocolate, and Fruit in the cup.
DarkCaramelDark ChocolateCocoa Powder+4
SCA 91.0
58CBI
$1.00/oz
Vespers Decaf
Cupping notes point toward Bittersweet Chocolate and Malt.
DarkDark ChocolateMalt
Shop 4.9 (72)
58CBI
$0.91/oz
Midnight Vigils Blend
Cupping notes point toward Bittersweet Chocolate, Vanilla Bean, and Chocolate Fudge.
DarkDark ChocolateVanillaHazelnut+2
SCA 90.0
58CBI
$0.91/oz
Midnight Blend Coffee: Midnight Vigils Blend
Think Chocolate Fudge, Scorched Cedar, and Roasted Hazelnut.
DarkDark ChocolateHazelnutFloral+1
SCA 90.0
57CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.79 to $1.51/oz
Limited comparison
MediumMilk ChocolateAlmondDate+1
SCA 90.0
56CBI
$1.17/oz
Typical $0.84 to $1.60/oz
Limited comparison
Thanksgiving Blend
Think Dark Chocolate, Malt, and Dark Cherry.
Medium-DarkDark ChocolateCherryHoney+2
50CBI
$1.32/oz
Typical $0.78 to $1.49/oz
Limited comparison
MediumMelonPearJasmine+1
49CBI
$1.32/oz
Typical $0.99 to $1.90/oz
Limited comparison
Jingle Bell Java
Think Cinnamon, Bourbon, and White Chocolate.
CinnamonWhiskeyWhite Chocolate
41CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.89 to $1.70/oz
Limited comparison
Snickering Monk Candy Bar
Cupping notes point toward Chocolate, Roasted Peanuts, and Caramel.
ChocolatePeanutCaramel
41CBI
$1.10/oz
Typical $0.89 to $1.70/oz
Limited comparison
Also available · subscriptions, sample packs, gear
Pumpkin Spice Coffee
Not much signal yet; the detail page has what we know.
Shop 4.9 (571)
59CBI
$1.10/oz
LightPearJasmineWiney
43CBI
$1.25/oz
Flavor of the Month Subscription
Roaster flags Vanilla, Berry, and Chocolate in the cup.
41CBI
$1.10/oz
Archived (33)
Honduras Liquidambar Microlot
Yellow Honey lot with Dark Cherry, Herbal Honey, and Raisin in the cup.
Honduras · Yellow Honey
MediumCherryHoneyRaisin+5
SCA 93.0
70CBI
$1.25/oz
Out of stock
MediumCocoaAppleNutty
Shop 4.7 (18)
60CBI
$1.20/oz
Out of stock
Medium
SCA 93.0
59CBI
$1.20/oz
Out of stock
MediumStone FruitMilk ChocolateHazelnut+4
SCA 93.0
58CBI
$1.20/oz
Out of stock
Medium-LightFloralChocolateCitrus+5
SCA 93.0
58CBI
$1.25/oz
Out of stock
Medium-LightStone FruitCocoaWiney
56CBI
$1.41/oz
Out of stock
MediumGrapeChocolateLemon+4
SCA 92.0
55CBI
$1.25/oz
Out of stock
Light
SCA 91.0
51CBI
$1.41/oz
Out of stock
Medium-LightLimeGrapefruitFloral+1
51CBI
$1.25/oz
Out of stock
MediumCherryCocoaHoneysuckle
49CBI
$1.66/oz
Out of stock
Breakfast Blend: Special Edition
Cupping notes point toward Raisin, Apricot, and Milk Chocolate.
MediumRaisinApricotMilk Chocolate+1
49CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
PineappleMangoGuava+1
48CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Pascha Java
Cupping notes point toward Cinnamon, Bourbon, and White Chocolate.
CinnamonWhiskeyWhite Chocolate
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Dark Chocolate Toffee
Roaster flags Dark Chocolate, Toffee, and Caramel in the cup.
MediumDark ChocolateToffeeCaramel
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Roaster flags White Chocolate Sweetness, Buttery Macadamia, and Tropical Fruit Hints in the cup.
White ChocolateTropical Fruit
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Butterscotch
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Dad's Blend
Roaster flags Dark Chocolate, Nutty, and Charred Wood in the cup.
DarkDark ChocolateNuttySmoky
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
VanillaOverall Sweet
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Cinnamon Coffee Cake
Cupping notes point toward Cinnamon Spice, Brown Sugar, and Hazelnut.
CinnamonHazelnutBrown Sugar+1
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Midnight Vigils Blend: Special Edition
Cupping notes point toward Dark Chocolate, Pine, and Orange Zest.
DarkDark ChocolateOrangePeach
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
DarkVanillaOverall Sweet
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Cowboy Blend: Special Edition
Roaster flags Cocoa, Caramel, and Vanilla in the cup.
Medium-DarkCocoaCaramelVanilla
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
LightRaspberryDark Chocolate
46CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Chocolate Cherry
Roaster flags Cherry and Dark Chocolate in the cup.
DarkCherryDark Chocolate
45CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Mystic Monk Blend — Special Edition
Roaster flags Spice and Dark Chocolate in the cup.
Medium-DarkSpiceDark Chocolate
45CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Chocolate Carmel
Cupping notes point toward Chocolate and Caramel.
ChocolateCaramel
45CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Coconut Margarita
Roaster flags Coconut Liqueur and Coconut in the cup.
Coconut
45CBI
$1.10/oz
Out of stock
Flagship cafe
Retail location
Cody, WY
Open in maps →Monastery roastery in Wyoming selling coffee online; no public cafe mentioned.
For roasters
Cherrybook runs a monthly Roaster Spotlight Series featuring one roaster with an editorial piece and a giveaway. Interested in being featured? See the format or email josh@cherrybookcoffee.com.