Cherrybook.
Proud Mary Coffee

Old Mate

Washed80Strong
Old Mate by Proud Mary Coffee
Origin
Huila, CO
Farm / Co-op
—
Process
Washed
Altitude
—
Varietals
caturra,colombia
Harvest
—
Weight
268g
Bag price
$17.00
Price / oz
$1.80/oz
Brew
—

As cupped

caramel · vanilla · milk chocolate

Currently out of stock at the roaster. Subscribe to get an email when it returns.

Cherry's Index

Evidence-of-quality score, not a cup score. Methodology

80

Strong

Preliminary

Confidence33% coverage / 3 of 7 signals

Score is partially shrunk toward a neutral 50 — read directionally until more source families land. Coverage is signal availability, not cup quality; missing sources are dropped, the remaining weights are renormalized, and the result is shrunk toward a neutral 50 baseline by 18% so a single thin signal can’t carry the score on its own.

Missing: SCA grade, Coffee Review, Buyer reviews, Cherrybook tastings

  • YouTube reviews
    Sentiment from third-party YouTube reviewer mentions
    90/ 30% weight
  • Reddit sentiment
    Sentiment across specialty-coffee discussion
    85/ 55% weight
  • Roaster transparency
    Producer / farm / lot disclosure depth
    60/ 15% weight

Bonuses applied

  • Sprudge press coverage
    This roaster has been featured by Sprudge
    +2
  • Editorial coverage cluster
    This roaster has 3+ recent editorial mentions across trade press
    +1

Renormalized base 82.7 shrunk to 77.0 at 83% confidence + bonuses = 80.

Sensory profileestimated

Flavor wheel

Comps & alternatives

Tasting flight

Taste this against three others Cherry picks.

Brew a set side-by-side. Cherry varies the picks along axes that pair with this lot; origin, process, roast, or producer; so you learn the difference, not just drink four good cups.

Build the flight

Reference · About the varietal & origin

About Proud Mary Coffee

Community reputation · Reddit

Cult favorite· sentiment 85/100

Proud Mary is widely recognized as a top-tier roaster, frequently mentioned alongside other industry leaders like Onyx and Tim Wendelboe. While customers often note that their "deluxe" pour-over menu and beans are expensive, they are generally considered high-quality and worth experiencing. Recent feedback includes a single report of inconsistent roast quality in a subscription, but this is balanced by their responsive customer service and a strong reputation for excellent cafe experiences in Portland and Austin.

high-end 'deluxe' coffee selectionpremium pricingexcellent cafe experiencefrequent industry leader comparisonsresponsive customer serviceconsistent quality reputation
Threads cited (10)

Press · Sprudge

On YouTube

7 videos · 27k combined views

Outside coverage consistently positions Proud Mary Coffee as a pioneer in the ultra-premium coffee segment. Reviewers emphasize the brand's commitment to transparency and education regarding the value of high-end specialty beans. The roaster is recognized for its unique cafe experiences and its willingness to challenge consumer perceptions through exclusive, high-cost offerings. Coverage also highlights the founder's background in art and hospitality as a driving force behind the brand's focus on storytelling and presentation.

Ultra-premium coffee auctionsFocus on customer educationArtistic approach to hospitalityUnique coffee freezer systemsChallenging price point perceptionsEmphasis on staff expertise

From Proud Mary Coffee

Coverage from others

← Back to browse

Proud Mary Coffee

$1.80/oz· $17/bag

Out of stock