Cherrybook.
Sump Coffee

Colombia Edison Argote

Anaerobic Natural76Strong
Colombia Edison Argote by Sump Coffee
Origin
Huila, CO
Farm / Co-op
—
Altitude
1700–2000 m
Varietals
sl28
Harvest
—
Weight
369g
Bag price
$33.50
Price / oz
$2.57/oz
Brew
—

As cupped

twizzler · green apple candy · port wine

Buy on Sump Coffee →

Price and availability set by the roaster.

Cherry's Index

Evidence-of-quality score, not a cup score. Methodology

76

Strong

Preliminary

Confidence33% coverage / 3 of 7 signals

Score is partially shrunk toward a neutral 50 — read directionally until more source families land. Coverage is signal availability, not cup quality; missing sources are dropped, the remaining weights are renormalized, and the result is shrunk toward a neutral 50 baseline by 18% so a single thin signal can’t carry the score on its own.

Missing: SCA grade, Coffee Review, Buyer reviews, Cherrybook tastings

  • YouTube reviews
    Sentiment from third-party YouTube reviewer mentions
    85/ 30% weight
  • Reddit sentiment
    Sentiment across specialty-coffee discussion
    80/ 55% weight
  • Roaster transparency
    Producer / farm / lot disclosure depth
    70/ 15% weight

Bonuses applied

  • Sprudge press coverage
    This roaster has been featured by Sprudge
    +2
  • Stale-stock demotion
    This lot has been listed in stock for an extended time; specialty coffee freshness degrades over weeks
    +-1

Renormalized base 80.0 shrunk to 74.8 at 83% confidence + bonuses = 76.

Sensory profileestimated

Flavor wheel

Comps & alternatives

Tasting flight

Taste this against three others Cherry picks.

Brew a set side-by-side. Cherry varies the picks along axes that pair with this lot; origin, process, roast, or producer; so you learn the difference, not just drink four good cups.

Build the flight

Reference · About the varietal & origin

About Sump Coffee

Community reputation · Reddit

Well-regarded· sentiment 80/100

Sump Coffee is recognized as a reputable roaster based in St. Louis. Users frequently mention them alongside other respected local roasters when discussing coffee road trips or seeking specific flavor profiles like the "blueberry bomb" Yirgacheffe. While some users have noted challenges in dialing in their beans or comparing them to other high-end shops, the feedback is consistently respectful and acknowledges the quality of their product. Note: Many search results for "sump" in coffee subreddits refer to machine parts (e.g., espresso machine sumps/drip trays), which should be filtered out when evaluating the roaster's reputation.

St. Louis staplenoted for blueberry flavor profileshigh-quality specialty roasterfrequent recommendation for STL coffee tours
Threads cited (10)

Press · Sprudge

On YouTube

7 videos · 315k combined views

Outside coverage consistently characterizes Sump Coffee as a project driven by the uncompromising philosophy of founder Scott Carey. Reviewers highlight his rejection of traditional blending practices in favor of showcasing the distinct seasonal and varietal characteristics of individual beans. Furthermore, coverage emphasizes that while the roaster cultivates a unique and intentional physical environment, the primary reputation of the brand remains firmly rooted in the technical quality of the coffee itself.

Prioritization of bean individuality over consistencyRejection of traditional blending practicesFounder driven roasting philosophyEmphasis on seasonal coffee characteristicsIntentional and non traditional shop environment

From Sump Coffee

Coverage from others

← Back to browse

Sump Coffee

$2.57/oz· $34/bag

Buy →